Human Cloning 'Is This Going to Be the New Moral Battleground Between West and East?'

On April 3, 2002, Dr. Severino Antinori announced heDr Antinori faces the outrage of those who oppose
had successfully implanted a cloned embryo into athe procedure on ethical and moral grounds. The
woman and that she was eight weeks pregnant. Dr.practice of human cloning is banned in Europe and
Antinori made his announcement while speaking at aformal legislation is now going through Congress in
conference on Healthcare Ethics in Abu Dhabi, Unitedthe United States. It is because of this reason that it
Arab Emirates. Sharing the stage with Dr. Antinoriis of more than passing interest that the 'world
was Dr. Haris Silajdzic, a former Bosnian Prime Ministerbreaking' announcement was made at the Zayed
and Hisham Yousuf, a representative of theCentre in Abu Dhabi, as I feel this underscores a
Cairo-based Arab League. Dr. Antinori refused tosubtle continuing shift of the centre of cloning
disclose either the location or the nationality of hisresearch from the western World to Middle Eastern
pregnant patient. He admitted that there was 'riskand Asian localities. The United States has recently
involved' but said he had pursued screening to reduceplaced a five-year moratorium and ban on human
the risk of any deformity before the embryo wascloning describing it as 'a violation of human rights'. It
implanted and that the outcomes of cloning differedhas also allowed countries such as India and
widely between species. Dr. Antinori also insisted thatSingapore to pursue stem cell technology on its
he was interested in therapeutic cloning and had tobehalf. It is widely rumoured that China has already
pursue his work in that area in other countries as it iscloned many human embryos to use in therapeutic
outlawed in Italy.cloning and stem cell research. It now appears that
In 1998, Dr Antinori announced plans to use cloningthe United Arab Emirates is interested in promoting
technology to help infertile couples have children.the Zayed Centre in Abu Dhabi in a new role of
British scientists to produce Dolly the sheep, theencouraging evolving scientific research within the
world's first vertebrate clone made from an adultArab World. It is also acknowledged that officials
mammalian cell, had pioneered the technology. Insuch as the UAE Minister of Health Under-secretary
2001, he predicted that he would complete the firstDr. Abdul Rahim Jaafar has more than a passing
human cloning operation within 18 months. Theinterest in making his nation the centre of cloning
56-year-old was previously best known for his workresearch. He already has stated that he intends to
in in vitro fertilisation, and in particular for enablinggroup other Arab League countries, the East
women in their 50s and 60s to give birth. He shot toMediterranean Region Office of the World Health
prominence in 1994 when he helped a 63-year-oldOrganization, the Islamic Organization for Medical
woman to have a baby by implanting a donor'sServices and the International Association of Bioethics
fertilised egg in her uterus, making her the oldesttogether for the 2004 Congress of Bioethics, with
known women in the world to give birth. Dr Antinorithe UAE as a possible venue for the event. He
told an Italian newspaper recently that more thanstated recently that we should explore how to
1,500 couples had volunteered as candidates for hispreserve our fundamental human values and 'adhere
research programme, and it is known that he isto our respective religious teaching in channelling new
working in close co-operation with Dr Panos Zavos,scientific knowledge to benefit our fellow man'.
an American fertility expert.