What's Wrong With the 3 Strikes ISP Laws?

Many countries have started to pass what are calledjury. There can be a variety of people who violate
three strikes laws concerning internet connections.copyright that are connected to the same
This means that once the account owner's internetconnection, but the account owner is the one who is
connection has three copyright violations against itpenalized.
where that account had somehow accessedA second problem with these is that the account
information under copyright a third time, there wouldholder is the one that is punished and not the person
be some sort of penalty. Some countries cut thewho did it. If someone who accessed that internet
account owner off forever. Others have 6 monthconnection with or without the account holder's
periods along with some sort of fine. While it doespermission did download illegal material, the account
seem like a great idea on the surface of protectingowner gets in trouble. Even with encryption, there
copyright, it does have it's problems.are those who are good enough to break encryption
First of all, the account holder has no recourse. Manyand download illegal material. These are the real
times where there is a law one would hope thatcriminals but the account owner is hurt. The issue
there would be a way of defending oneself ifwith this is that it will only logically lead to account
accused. There is no way of going to court andowners never sharing their internet access. There are
trying to prove an alternative to the accusation. It'scoffee shop owners and pub owners who have run
sad that in countries that have court systemsinto a problem with laws like these and shut off their
intended to let the accused defend themselves thatfree wi-fi since they don't want to get in trouble.
copyright holders and ISPs become the judge and